“Those were pretty fantastic,” Friedberg tells EW.

“The combination of the two of them going for it.

But this was when Phil was all in.

ABC’s “Modern Family” - Season Two

Karen Neal/ABC via Getty Images

It was great.”

“But it was perfect for Haley.”

Claire as Little Bo-Peep (season 4)

The next Halloween episode came inseason 4.

ABC’s “Modern Family” - Season Two

Karen Neal/ABC/Getty Images

“It ended up as this very elaborate Bo-Peep costume,” explains Freidberg.

“I loved making this one.

It was so perfect for Julie Bowen.

ABC’s “Modern Family” - Season Two

Karen Neal/ABC/Getty Images

She looked so sweet and angelic.

It was the perfect storybook character for her to play.”

What could go wrong?

ABC’s “Modern Family” – Season Four

Peter “Hopper” Stone/ABC via Getty Images

“It was fun to do both the cute side and the scary side of the same character.”

The end result was really spectacular.

It was really, really fun to do."

ABC’s “Modern Family” – Season Four

Peter “Hopper” Stone/ABC/Getty Images

Navigating such a crazy costume was so funny, to make and to watch."

So it wasn’t a Halloween episode, but it totally was."

“Eric as Meghan Markle was absolutely hilarious,” says Chilton.

ABC’s “Modern Family” - Season Six

John Fleenor/ABC/Getty Images

We got her exact hat made and we got a perfect wig, and he looked pretty great.

It was just so funny."

“Mitch is such a Harry look-alike!”

manny-modern-family

ABC

says Chilton, referring to both men’s red hair.

“I thought that was so good.”

JULIE BOWEN, TY BURRELL

Ron Tom/ABC

ERIC STONESTREET

Tony Rivetti/ABC

JESSE TYLER FERGUSON

Tony Rivetti/ABC