I kept yelling out, Weve gotta do an Extra!

and we did a glorious one.

TheExtrareunion also featured a 350-pound anniversary cake, made by Cake Boss Buddy Valastro, and plenty of reminiscing.

EXTRA_0109

Credit: Robert Voets/Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc.

While chatting with EW, McGrath opened up about one of his most memorableExtramoments.

My favorite interview was with Brian Wilson, revealed McGrath.

He got up, he clapped his hands, and went, Food!'

McGrath recounted with a laugh.

Being like the first story for the first show ofExtra, I think thats pretty exciting!

I get to solidify my black girl magic[laughs].

Anytime I get to be around her is a special time.

CelebrateExtras 25th anniversary by watching its very first interview with Oprah below.