Then, on the 21st occurrence, it did.
And she cast it for Wendell.
How epic was it?

Robert Voets/CBS (3)
The tie vote is up there, he says.
Id have to really think about the ones that are above it, but its top three.
Because weve never been able to do that.
Ive never been able to walk out and say, Im gonna read the votes.
As juiced as viewers were to see what would happen.
Probst was even more amped in the moment.
Here, he talks about what he remembers out how it went down.
Its a taxing thing to doSurvivor.
Youre mentally fatigued like the players are, even though youre eating and drinking and all that.
So Im excited that the season is over, because my brain is out of power.
And [EP Mat Van Wagenen] is looking at me going [silently mouthing the word tie].
And I went What?
And he went [silently mouthing the word tie].
All I see is the mouth opening.
And I had this renewed energy.
So that to me is a salient memory because I was so tired and then WHOOSH!
woke right back up!
It was just great.
And also we had one of the best final Tribals ever.
I had watched these guys [mimics heads being hit back and forth] like a slugfest.
And then it was five to five.
It should be five to five!
They both played killer games.
I was sitting at final Tribal going I dont know, Doms making a pretty good argument right now.
Watch the video above where Probst shares his reaction to the milestone moment.