And John Ford belongs on anyone’s Mt.

Rushmore of great directors.

But it’s noCitizen Kane.

how-green-was-my-valley-citizen-kane

Everett Collection (2)

It isn’t now and it wasn’t then.

It’s the Academy that would wind up looking foolish in the eyes of history.

Albert Finney forMurder on the Orient Express.

art-carney

Everett Collection (2); Paramount/Kobal/REX/Shutterstock

All of the others would be nominated again.

In the immortal words of another famous Pesci role,“Do Iamuseyou, Academy?

1939 has been called (more than once) the Greatest Year in Hollywood History.

MY COUSIN VINNY, Marisa Tomei, 1992. ©20th Century Fox/courtesy Everett Collection

Everett Collection

The performances weren’t bad either.

Laurence Olivier inWuthering Heights, Jimmy Stewart inMr.

Smith Goes to Washington, and Clark Gable inGone With the Wind, to name a few.

forrest-gump-pulp-fiction

Moviestore/REX/Shutterstock; Everett Collection

None of them won.

That honor would go to Robert Donat for the pre-war weepieGoodbye, Mr. Chips.

But you are no Cate Blanchett, so fantastically layered and irascible asno mans Elizabeth.

way-we-were-song

Everett Collection (2)

This was a make-good award, plain and simple reparations for past snubs.

That’s just baloney.

Winning for that film makes even less sense.

donat-win

Everett Collection (4)

Especially considering that Kelly went up against Judy Garland inA Star Is Born.

There’s no competition there.

It’s big and bright and busy…and there isn’t an honest moment in it.

paltrow-blanchett

Laurie Sparham/Miramax/Universal/Kobal/REX/Shutterstock; Everett Collection

David Fincher’sThe Social data pipe, on the other hand, was a movie of its moment.

Maybethemovie of its moment.

Hollywood, once again, was years behind the curve.

kevin-costner-win

Everett Collection (2)

CN

2002 Jim Broadbent wins Best Actor over Ben Kingsley as Don f—‘in Logan?!

Don’t even try.

But her warbling ingenue Mia alsofelt(unlike her spectacular turn inThe Favouritethis year) like a Globes-caliber performance.

pacino-eastwood

Everett Collection (2)

), and Yalitza Aparicio (Roma) was perceived to be splitting the table scraps of remaining votes.

rocky-win

Everett Collection (2)

crash

Lorey Sebastian/Lionsgate; Everett Collection (2)

chariots-of-fire

Everett Collection; Moviestore/REX/Shutterstock (2)

tommy-lee-jones-ralph-fiennes

Everett Collection (2)

country-girl-star-is-born

Everett Collection (2)

greatest-show-on-earth-high-noon

Everett Collection (2)

kings-speech-social-network

Laurie Sparham; Merrick Morton

iris-sexy-beast

Everett Collection; Moviestore/REX/Shutterstock

birdman-boyhood

Fox Searchlight Pictures; Matt Lankes/IFC Films

emma-stone-huppert

Dale Robinette/Lionsgate; Guy Ferrandis/Sony Pictures Classics

oscar-Upsets

Atsushi Nishijima/Fox Searchlight; Graeme Hunter/Sony Pictures Classics